• 0 Posts
  • 636 Comments
Joined 6 months ago
cake
Cake day: January 2nd, 2025

help-circle
  • Hahahahaha, oh yea, the Year of the Linux Desktop - been hearing that since 2000.

    Look, Linux is a brilliant server OS, brilliant embedded/dedicated device OS. But as a desktop it’s very problematic. It can be a great desktop OS, if you have very clear requirements, and know those requirements will never increase to include things from the Windows world, especially for end users who frankly have little tech understanding of any OS.

    The very first issue they’re going to run into is Excel. None of the open-source competitors come close, and any business/analysis will use it.

    Oh, just RDP to a virtual desktop? Then why bother with Linux, which merely adds a layer of complexity?

    The support issues/costs will skyrocket.

    What they did a few months ago made more sense - use it in a small group, one with nominal requirements. Run that for a couple years, then expand a little. This gives IT time to flesh out issues and ensures they only get a small set of issues, affecting a small group, at any one time. It also allows for changing distro or shell with far less effort.

    I’ve done this multiple times with other types of systems - run the new in a small group, not replacing the old entirely. Over time we identify pain points, develop work around or new architectural approaches, so when we finally full switch over and retire the old system it’s a minor change.



















  • Just use the OptiPlex for everything. The RPi lacks the horsepower, and storage capability.

    I’m currently using a 7 year old OptiPlex SFF as a NAS, backup point, media converter, and media server. I’ve upgraded the storage drive to 8TB.

    I do have another old NAS I use only to duplicate my data store locally (I keep 3 local copies of data, and a cloud backup).

    The OptiPlex draws 15w at idle, about 85w when converting video. My NAS draws about 5w at idle. I initially tried serving media from the NAS, but it’s performance is frankly abysmal. Instead I run Media Monkey, Jellyfin, and another media server on the Dell, which has no problem streaming to my crappy Samsung TV (not using an app, just the crappy built-in DLNA client) It works even better with decent devices, like my phone, laptop, iPad.

    Your biggest concern with that Dell is the power consumption. As I said, mine happens to draw 15w at idle - I got lucky

    What are the specs on your OptiPlex? Is it a mini tower or SFF? That would help more than just telling us the model.

    Depending on your sensitivity to failures (drives die) I’d get 2 data drives for the Dell and mirror them, using the current drive just for the OS.



OSZAR »